Real estate team hiring, why role fit matters more than talent

My first hire still calls me, 16 years later. He’s also the one I got wrong. I came into real estate carrying a law firm’s habits. A firm runs on handing consequential work to capable people, so delegating was the easy part. Then came an American office of one and a strange gift: Knowing exactly how to delegate, with nobody to delegate to.

So the question was never whether to build a team. Only how fast.

Two jobs, one person

The playbook says your first hire is an administrator. Mine was a buyer agent, and the business could hold one salary, so he carried the admin work too. Half his day was showings. The other half was paperwork, and the small salary was really for that half.

The incentives were wrong from the first paycheck.

Watch a great administrator work and you’ll see somebody introverted and sharp, happiest with the door closed and the file open. A great buyer agent walks into an open house and leaves with three new friends. He was the second kind all the way through, and out there he was very good. The paperwork was never going to be him. He got frustrated. So did I.

Ask me whether I saw it coming. I didn’t.

The rule I give new team leaders now is simple. The day you have three months of an administrator’s salary in the bank, make the hire. I waited because it didn’t feel affordable, and the waiting cost more than the salary would have. The system I trained in says a right admin returns her pay five times over, because every hour they take off your desk goes back into the work that brings in business. Mine have returned closer to ten.

The hire after him was my first real administrator, and she stayed less than a year. We argued nearly every day, and every evening she built systems, and when she left, the systems stayed and trained everyone who came after her. Nobody tested either of them for the seat. Back then, nobody tested anybody.

A test at the door

This industry spent a long time telling me teams don’t work, that real estate is an individual sport. Then I sat down for an interview at Keller Williams, where I still work today, and nobody asked me about splits or lead flow. They wanted to know how I would build a team.

The training that followed handed me names for the roles and a way to hand work off without the client losing track of who’s holding it. There’s a chart in Gary Keller‘s “The Millionaire Real Estate Agent” that builds a team one seat at a time. It ended my improvising.

Nobody joins this team on a feeling anymore. Every candidate since around 2014 has taken a personality assessment before any offer: a DISC profile in the early years, now the KPA, a deeper read of a person. Twelve years of results, and not one has come back the opposite of who the person turned out to be. People surprise you in degree, not in kind.

More than once a profile has moved a good agent into a different seat, and the seat fit.

The discipline runs both directions. We interview ten to twenty people for one seat, and a new hire gets a 100 days: 30 of training, 30 of working while we watch, 30 on their own, and 10 days’ grace. If it’s wrong, you know by 60 days. Slow to hire, quick to fire. The longer the wrong person stays, the harder the goodbye, because you start depending on them.

Character before production

The training I came up in leads with its hiring standard, character before production, and it sounds soft until you try hiring that way. Production is a number someone posted last year in a market that no longer exists. Character is how a person behaves at nine at night when a deal is coming apart and the client is scared.

Hire for the second one and the first one follows.

Sellers arrive wanting three things: the highest price, the lowest commission, and a closing by the weekend. Somebody has to reset all three without losing the room, kindly and directly, as the expert. That is the listing agent’s chair. My best buyer agents are people-pleasers, and I mean that as praise. It’s the wrong instinct for that chair.

Small on purpose

There are teams in my market running 50 agents, and honestly I don’t know how they keep track of everybody. In 2025 my agents closed $65.5 million in volume, and the roster has never been larger than ten.

My admins stay. Eight years, 12 years and counting.

Between them, my agents speak seven languages. We hire people who sound like the families sitting across from us. A nervous first-time buyer sits down at our table, hears their own language come back at them, and everything after that is easier.

New team leaders ask me about doubt more than anything else. Through my first four or five years, real estate felt temporary, and law felt like the thing waiting once life settled down. The team got built during those years anyway, one hire at a time, by somebody who kept choosing to stay another year.

So, back to my first hire. I know exactly which seat that man should have been sitting in, and these days the seat gets built before the person walks in.

None of it felt certain when I started. I just kept hiring.

Shabana Pathan leads the Shabana Pathan Group at Keller Williams in Bethlehem, Penn.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of HousingWire’s editorial department and its owners. To contact the editor responsible for this piece: [email protected].